Open Letter from Chamber to the Environment Officer & his Response

Wednesday 21 December 12:00

Chamber has sent an open letter to the Environment Minister re proposed Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL),

Dear Minister,

First of all I would like to thank you for attending our Building & Development Committee meeting on Wednesday 9th November 2016, to update the committee and discuss the proposal of a Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL).

Chamber is always encouraged by the willingness of government Ministers to engage with our committees and we were very reassured to hear from you, that if your consultation and subsequent CIL report proves that such a levy is not viable, then you will not seek to pursue it as policy for Jersey.

As part of your investigation, we would like to suggest that your research thoroughly examines the potential negative impact any such levy is likely to have on local development and the wider island economy, as we believe CIL has the potential for far reaching negative effects that will be felt outside the construction industry.

Following on from our meeting with you, the committee has a number of serious concerns regarding CIL, which are outlined for you below:

  • CIL, despite being called a ‘levy’ is in fact another tax for Jersey, specifically the construction industry
  • A tax for every development and construction project, whether a private individual or commercial property owner is increasing the size of their build or making use of additional land.
  • A tax that will be inconsistently administered, with varying rates depending on each properties location, with countryside sites taxed at a higher rates than town.
  • A tax which is complex and will generate additional administrative burdens and confusion, as a Planning Obligation Agreement (POA) will still have to remain in place for areas where a site specific improvement is required.
  • An additional tax, on top of planning fees, planning requirements, parish requirements, HSPC, POA’s, new insulation standards, repeated appeals, additional legal fees and changes to plans.
  • A tax that will stop development. Property owners and developers will only look to develop a site if the project is financially viable. An additional tax, which further erodes at profit margins will be the tipping point of work going ahead or not.

While the committee acknowledge the Minister is considering CIL, in order to raise money to improve areas of St Helier, we feel it is unfair to simply tax one sector of the economy when our capital is used by everyone. Surely improvements for town, should be funded from a central infrastructure pot, not home or land owners or developers who wish to make changes to their existing property.

We would strongly advise that your department thoroughly research similar schemes which the UK government had previously considered and who have subsequently dismissed them, due to similar concerns we have listed above.

As I mentioned at the start of this letter, the committee are encouraged by your reassurance that CIL is not a fait accompli and that should your consultation and CIL report prove that such a levy is not viable, that you will not seek to pursue it as policy for Jersey. To be clear the Jersey Chamber of Commerce, Building & Development Committee would strongly recommend you do not introduce this policy in Jersey.

We look forward to hearing from you once your CIL report is published.

Yours Sincerely,


Cathy Elliot,

On behalf of Jersey Chamber of Commerce Building & Development Committee.




  • Subsidised Skills Training for Employees Business Licensing | Social Security Department | States of Jersey

    › read more
  • Building a Foundation: Working with the Voluntary and Community Sector Where: St. Pauls Centre When: Wednesday 26th September Time: 1pm to 4pm Cost: FREE

    › read more
  • Ibex Education - Excel Introduction

    › read more
  • Ibex Education - Excel at Intermediate Level

    › read more
  • Ibex Education - Excel at Advanced Level

    › read more
  • Marbral Advisory - Blockchain for lawyers Early Bird: €75.00 - Standard: €115.00

    › read more
  • Marbral Advisory - Blockchain Basics Early Bird: €75.00 - Standard: €115.00

    › read more
  • A Very Special Evening of Celebration! - Jersey Chamber of Commerce 250th Gala Event You are Invited to a Very Special Evening of Celebration!

    › read more
  • GTA Guernsey - IoD Accelerated Company Direction Programme Course Cost: £5,750.00 | Course Length: 5 days (generally 08:30-19:00)12-16 November 2018 |

    › read more
  • Jersey Business - Enterprise Week 2018 FREE EVENT

    › read more

Chamber Knowledgebase

Our frequently asked questions

Contact Magazine

Click here to view the latest digital issue of the Channel Islands Business Magazine.

Jersey Airport / Harbours

The latest arrivals and departures, select a link above

Charity of Choice 2018

Click here to learn more about the vital work of the Jersey Employment Trust and how you can help.

The Benefits of Membership

Networking opportunities, including our popular luncheons
Topical seminar programme
Support and guidance on doing business in Jersey

And become one of over 500 member businesses supporting Chamber in its aim of ensuring that local business is at the heart of a thriving and diverse local economy.

Call 01534 724536
› About Chamber

Copyright © Jersey Chamber 2012 - The Jersey Chamber of Commerce welcomes your comments and views. However, the posting of comments is subject to our terms which can be read here. Comments posted by users of this site are not the Chamber's comments nor do they represent the views of the Jersey Chamber of Commerce.

↑ Back to top